The Buccaneer: A Waterfront Brunch Worth Discovering

Buccaneer Singer Island Review

For a destination surrounded by water, Palm Beach has surprisingly few places to enjoy a leisurely brunch with a front-row seat to the marina. So when we discovered The Buccaneer Waterfront Bar & Grill, tucked along Lake Drive in Palm Beach Shores, we couldn't help wondering how this place had managed to stay off our dining radar.

Just a short drive from West Palm Beach, Buccaneer offers something increasingly appealing in our busy dining scene: a relaxed waterfront setting, boats bobbing just beyond the terrace, and a menu that gives seafood as much attention as traditional brunch favorites. Across the water sits Peanut Island, adding another layer of coastal scenery to an already inviting setting.

But the view is only part of the story. The restaurant is led by Executive Chef Paul Niedermann, winner of Season 9 of Hell's Kitchen, whose approach to cooking is considerably more approachable than his television credentials might suggest. Our brunch moved from tender olive oil-poached rock shrimp to a generously filled Lobster BLTA, an impressive Crab Cake Benedict, and a tropical take on classic Key lime pie.

What surprised us most was how naturally everything came together. The atmosphere was polished without feeling formal, the hospitality was welcoming, and the food gave us reasons to pay attention beyond the waterfront scenery.

And not every brunch comes with its own resident pufferfish.

THE QUICK TAKE

  • Best for: Waterfront brunch, casual weekend gatherings, seafood lovers, visiting friends and family, and locals looking for a relaxed alternative to the usual Palm Beach and West Palm Beach dining circuit.

  • Cuisine: Contemporary American coastal cuisine, with seafood-forward brunch selections and elevated comfort food.

  • Vibe: Casual coastal elegance. Beautiful marina views, relaxed surroundings, and a welcoming atmosphere without unnecessary formality.

  • What to order: Olive Oil-Poached Rock Shrimp, Crab Cake Benedict, Lobster BLTA, and Mango Key Lime Pie.

  • Price level: $$$ Upscale casual pricing, with satisfying portions that make several seafood dishes feel like good value.

  • Watch for: Waterfront terrace seating, weekend brunch availability, and the opportunity to arrive by boat with advance coordination.

  • Would I return? Absolutely. The Crab Cake Benedict alone deserves a second visit, but the combination of food, atmosphere, and marina views makes Buccaneer an appealing addition to our weekend brunch rotation.


What to Order at The Buccaneer

Chef Paul Niedermann's menu moves comfortably between coastal seafood and familiar American favorites, emphasizing approachable dishes prepared with care. There is no shortage of traditional brunch offerings around Palm Beach, but Buccaneer distinguishes itself by giving seafood a particularly prominent role.

During our visit, we were impressed not only by the flavor and preparation of the dishes but also by the generous portions. At a time when upscale restaurant pricing doesn't always translate into satisfying value, that distinction matters.

Olive Oil-Poached Rock Shrimp: Tender and Generously Served

Our brunch began with the Olive Oil-Poached Rock Shrimp, a dish that immediately caught our attention for its generous presentation.

A substantial serving of small rock shrimp arrived dressed with jalapeño, red onion, lemon, and roasted garlic, accompanied by warm focaccia.

Rock shrimp can be challenging to prepare well. Their small size leaves little margin for overcooking, and they can quickly lose their tenderness.

Here, the shrimp retained a pleasing, delicate texture without becoming rubbery or overly firm. The lemon and garlic provided brightness and savory depth, while the accompanying vegetables added contrast.

What I particularly appreciated was the portion. Rather than presenting a few shrimp scattered decoratively across an oversized plate, the kitchen served a satisfying quantity, making it a natural appetizer to share.

For seafood lovers, it's an excellent introduction to the menu.

Crab Cake Benedict | Brunch Menu Buccaneer Singer Island

Crab Cake Benedict: A Brunch Standout

If there's one dish I would encourage brunch enthusiasts to order, it's the Crab Cake Benedict.

This seafood-forward take on the traditional Eggs Benedict pairs crab cakes with poached eggs, English muffins, basil hollandaise, and breakfast potatoes.

What impressed me most was the crab cake itself. Rather than the dense, heavily bound versions that sometimes rely too much on filler, this crab cake had a lighter texture and a notably flavorful character. The quality of the crab remained central to the dish.

The basil hollandaise added a welcome herbal dimension to the sauce's familiar richness, while the poached eggs brought the elements together. The accompanying breakfast potatoes offered a satisfying textural contrast and made the dish feel complete without needing additional sides.

During our meal, we found ourselves comparing the crab cake with others we've enjoyed around Palm Beach. Buccaneer's version stood out for its lightness and the quality of the crab. It's a thoughtfully prepared Benedict that delivers more than an attractive presentation.

Lobster BLTA: Generosity Is Part of the Appeal

The Lobster BLTA is another dish that makes a compelling case for brunch at Buccaneer.

Served on naan bread, the sandwich combines lobster with bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, and lemon aioli.

The first thing we noticed was the amount of lobster.

This was not one of those seafood sandwiches where the featured ingredient disappears beneath the bread and accompanying garnishes. The filling was substantial, with enough lobster to make its presence unmistakable.

The bacon contributed savory richness, while the avocado and lemon aioli complemented the lobster without requiring an elaborate preparation.

Using naan rather than conventional sandwich bread gives the dish a slightly different character, providing a soft, substantial foundation for the generous filling. Accompanied by fries, it's a satisfying choice for someone who prefers a more substantial brunch entrée.

At $36 on the menu we reviewed, the Lobster BLTA sits at the higher end of casual brunch pricing. However, the quantity of lobster made the value proposition considerably more convincing than the price alone might suggest.

Brunch Menu Buccaneer Singer Island

Bloody Marys, Mimosas, and a Proper Weekend Brunch

Of course, brunch overlooking a marina calls for something refreshing in the glass.

We started with a Bloody Mary and a mimosa, both presented with the attention to detail one would expect from a restaurant with a more serious cocktail program.

The Bloody Mary arrived with a shrimp garnish and a colorful arrangement of accompaniments, giving it the kind of presentation that makes the first sip feel like an occasion.

More importantly, the cocktail itself was well-balanced. The seasoning and mixer added flavor without letting the drink's strength overwhelm the overall composition.

The mimosa provided a lighter, refreshing counterpart to the seafood dishes and the warm afternoon setting. Neither cocktail needed to be unnecessarily complicated. They simply complemented the experience.

Dessert | Brunch Menu Buccaneer Singer Island

Mango Key Lime Pie: A Personal Touch from Chef Paul

We finished brunch with the Mango Key Lime Pie, a tropical interpretation of one of Florida's most recognizable desserts.

The dessert combines the familiar citrus character of Key lime pie with mango, served over a graham cracker and Biscoff cookie crust with whipped cream.

What made this dessert particularly interesting was learning that Chef Paul personally prepares the pie.

There's something appealing about a chef with an accomplished restaurant background still taking a hands-on interest in a familiar dessert.

The combination of mango and Key lime gives it a distinctly South Florida character, while the cookie crust adds a richer, slightly spiced element to the classic preparation. After a brunch built around seafood and savory flavors, it was a fitting conclusion.

Not every dessert needs an elaborate presentation or an unfamiliar list of ingredients. Sometimes a thoughtful interpretation of a regional classic is exactly what the occasion calls for.

The Experience: Waterfront Dining Without the Formality

The Buccaneer's most immediate attraction is its location.

Unlike restaurants that offer only a distant glimpse of the Intracoastal, Buccaneer sits directly within an active marina. From the outdoor dining terrace, boats are only a short distance away, creating an unusually close connection to the waterfront.

The views extend toward Peanut Island, while the surrounding palms and landscaped lawn contribute to the relaxed coastal atmosphere.

During our visit, the patio felt particularly welcoming. Guests enjoyed their meals without any sense of urgency, and the overall setting encouraged lingering over another drink rather than rushing to the next destination.

Inside, the restaurant offers an entirely different but complementary experience.

Warm wood finishes, rich blue seating, maritime-inspired details, and a substantial bar give the dining room a polished, contemporary appearance. The space feels thoughtfully renovated without completely abandoning its nautical identity.

Buccaneer Singer Island Atmosphere

And then there's the pufferfish.

An aquarium near the bar houses a particularly memorable resident, bringing an unexpected touch of marine life into the dining experience.

It's a playful detail that makes Buccaneer feel less predictable than a conventional waterfront restaurant.

The restaurant also welcomes dogs, another appealing feature for locals who like to bring their four-legged companions along on weekend outings.

Perhaps most interestingly, Buccaneer is accessible by boat. During our conversation, we learned that visiting boaters can coordinate temporary dockage with the marina's dockmaster.

That gives the restaurant an identity beyond its view. It is part of the boating community rather than simply a place to watch boats pass.

Service: Warm, Attentive, and Very Professional

A beautiful waterfront setting can attract guests, but genuine hospitality is what encourages them to return. During our brunch, service was one of Buccaneer's strengths. Our server was friendly, professional, and attentive without being intrusive. She offered helpful recommendations, answered our questions, and kept the meal flowing smoothly.

The pacing felt appropriate for a leisurely weekend brunch. We never felt the table needed to be turned quickly, nor did the relaxed atmosphere come at the expense of attentive service.

Buccaneer Marina Singer Island

The Buccaneer: A Historic Marina Finds Its Second Act

The Buccaneer may feel like a new discovery to many local diners, but its history stretches back more than seven decades.

Established in 1956, Buccaneer Marina became an important part of the Palm Beach Shores boating community, building a reputation for sportfishing, sailfish tournaments, and Singer Island's social life.

For decades, it was a familiar waterfront gathering place. Eventually, the restaurant closed in the early 2000s, leaving a longtime local landmark without its original social centerpiece.

After an extensive restoration led by Sharfi Holdings, The Buccaneer Waterfront Bar & Grill officially reopened in March 2025.

The renovation sought to preserve elements of the property's maritime heritage while introducing a refreshed dining room, updated facilities, and a more contemporary hospitality experience. The result is a restaurant that acknowledges its past without feeling trapped by it.

Chef Paul Niedermann: From Hell's Kitchen to Singer Island

Chef Paul Niedermann's culinary background adds another interesting dimension to The Buccaneer's revival.

The South Florida native developed an early interest in cooking through his father, who was also a chef. He later studied at Johnson & Wales University and built a career working in professional kitchens.

He gained national recognition when he won Season 9 of FOX's Hell's Kitchen, the competitive cooking series hosted by Gordon Ramsay.

Following his television success, Niedermann worked within the BLT Steak restaurant group, developing experience in high-profile kitchens before eventually returning to South Florida.

But during our conversation, it became clear that his interest in Buccaneer extends beyond the opportunity to lead another restaurant.

An avid fisherman, Niedermann was naturally drawn to the marina's history and waterfront setting. He also appreciated the care invested in restoring the property.

His culinary philosophy reflects that connection. Rather than creating another formal restaurant reserved for special occasions, he aims to establish a place where guests feel comfortable returning regularly.

He said he wants people to enjoy high-quality food whether they arrive dressed for an evening out or stop by in a polo shirt after spending time on the water. It's an appealing philosophy, particularly in a dining market where polished surroundings can sometimes come with an unnecessarily formal atmosphere.

At Buccaneer, the ambition is to make thoughtful cooking feel approachable.

Is The Buccaneer Worth Visiting for Brunch?

For anyone searching for waterfront brunch near West Palm Beach or Palm Beach, The Buccaneer deserves serious consideration.

The setting alone makes it appealing. Waterfront restaurants aren't hard to find throughout South Florida, but relatively few offer this combination of an intimate marina atmosphere, relaxed dining, and a menu that puts seafood at the center of the brunch experience. More importantly, the food holds its own.

The rock shrimp demonstrated careful preparation and generous portioning. The Crab Cake Benedict offered a lighter, more flavorful interpretation of a familiar brunch favorite. The Lobster BLTA delivered the kind of substantial seafood filling that helps justify its premium pricing. And the Mango Key Lime Pie provided a personal connection to the chef's kitchen.

There's also something refreshing about the restaurant's lack of pretension.

Buccaneer doesn't appear interested in competing with Palm Beach's most fashionable brunch destinations. Instead, it offers a comfortable, waterfront experience supported by thoughtful cooking and attentive hospitality. For our first visit, that combination worked exceptionally well.

Would I return? Without hesitation. And now that Buccaneer is officially on our brunch radar, I suspect we won't be overlooking it again.

Go For

  • The waterfront setting: A genuinely marina-side dining experience with close-up boat views and sightlines toward Peanut Island.

  • The Crab Cake Benedict: A light, flavorful crab cake paired with poached eggs and basil hollandaise. One of the most memorable dishes of our visit.

  • The Olive Oil-Poached Rock Shrimp: Tender, generously portioned, and a natural choice for sharing.

  • The Lobster BLTA: A substantial serving of lobster on naan bread, complemented by bacon, avocado, and lemon aioli.

  • The relaxed atmosphere: Polished enough for a special brunch but comfortable enough to become a regular weekend destination.

  • The unexpected details: A resident pufferfish, dog-friendly hospitality, and the option to arrive by boat.

Be Prepared To

  • Spend a little more for seafood: The menu falls into the upscale casual category, though generous portions help justify the price.

  • Plan for the weather: Outdoor seating is part of the appeal, so warm afternoons and changing coastal conditions may influence your preferred table.

  • Check weekend brunch availability: Confirm current hours and reservation availability, especially when private events are scheduled.

  • Coordinate boat arrivals in advance: Visiting boaters should contact the marina to confirm temporary dockage and availability.

  • Make time to enjoy the surroundings: This is a restaurant better experienced at a leisurely pace than squeezed into a rushed weekend itinerary.


The Buccaneer Waterfront Bar & Grill

142 Lake Drive
Palm Beach Shores, FL 33404
Phone: (561) 360-1022

Official Website & Current Menus

Disclosure: Our brunch was hosted through a restaurant public relations invitation. As always, the observations and opinions expressed are my own.

Read More from Dining with Maria

For another distinctive marina-side dining experience, explore my Lamarina West Palm Beach review, where waterfront views come with an entirely different, more energetic yacht-club atmosphere.

If your idea of weekend brunch leans more toward classic Palm Beach elegance, read my Le Bilboquet Palm Beach review for a contrasting experience on Worth Avenue.

Next
Next

The Jupiter Grill: A Celebration of Land & Sea